What The Breakfast Club’s Netflix Move Can Teach Every Creator
By George Torres, Founder – Siembra Connect
There’s a moment many creators face.
A big platform comes knocking. The offer is real. The money is serious. This may even be a dream collabo. And for a split second… you may forget the people that made it all possible.
The Breakfast Club just had that moment.
In December 2025, iHeartMedia announced an exclusive video podcast deal with Netflix, bringing The Breakfast Club and 14 other shows onto the platform starting early 2026. The deal made headlines. Charlamagne posted. The culture clapped.
But there’s a number that didn’t make it into the press release.
The Power 105 YouTube page drew 27 million viewers in February 2025. One year later, that figure had fallen to 13 million… a decline directly tied to the Netflix deal.
That’s wasn’t just a dip. That’s half of their audience gone.
And here’s what makes that number so significant: those weren’t casual viewers. Those were the people who showed up every morning in the comments, shared clips, debated interviews, and made The Breakfast Club feel like their show. YouTube wasn’t just a distribution channel. For a show built on Black culture and community conversation, it was the town square.
The rub? Under the deal, video versions of full podcast episodes will no longer be distributed on YouTube. The exclusivity clause pulled the drawbridge up.
You Can Win the Deal and Lose the Culture.
Financially, the arrangement is attractive in the short term. Netflix pays upfront for a full year of content, a sum that likely outpaces what the show would earn through YouTube ad revenue alone. But industry observers caution that the long-term trade-off could be costly.
That’s the tension every creator has to sit with.
But before we even get to legacy… let’s talk about something more immediate. Something that gets overlooked in all the deal announcement excitement.
Netflix is not where people go to listen to podcasts.
That’s not an opinion. That’s consumer behavior.
YouTube accounted for 12.5% of all time spent streaming in the US in January 2026… more than any other service. People go to YouTube the way they used to flip on the radio. It’s ambient. It’s habitual. It fits into the commute, the gym, the morning routine. The algorithm meets you where you already are.
Netflix works completely differently. You have to decide to open it. You have to log in, navigate, search, and choose. Audio podcasts can be consumed while doing other activities like commuting or exercising… video podcasts on Netflix require more focused attention. That friction is by design for a prestige drama or a documentary. But a morning talk show? Your audience wants to catch the interview while they’re making coffee… not schedule it like a movie night.
The Breakfast Club built its entire identity on accessibility. It was the show that felt like it lived on the corner. Now it lives behind a subscription wall, inside an app people open to watch Squid Game.
There’s a mismatch there that no amount of Netflix marketing spend can fully fix. The audience feels it even if they can’t articulate it… which is why YouTube’s algorithm and shareability have made it a launchpad for podcast growth in a way Netflix simply cannot replicate. Clips don’t travel from Netflix the way they travel from YouTube. The comment section doesn’t exist. The recommended video rabbit hole that introduced someone new to the show every single day? Gone.
You can’t build community inside a closed room.
I Know This Because I Lived It.
Before podcasts were called podcasts (2007’ish), I hosted a show called Radio Capicu on Blog Talk Radio. It was community radio talk show, hosted virtually in audio first format that addressed trending topics in our culture, many of them not discussed in any form of media, The concept for the show was an extension of the Capicu Poetry, a live cultural showcase rooted in Brooklyn.
BTR was something special in a way that’s genuinely hard to explain to people who weren’t there. It was a live radio platform that let hosts take calls, interact with listeners in real time, and had social integration built into the experience in a way that… honestly, no platform has fully replicated since. The audience didn’t just listen. They participated. They felt ownership over the show. That wasn’t a feature. That was the whole culture.
Then I decided to move the show.
I wanted an in-studio experience. I wanted to host events, feed off live energy of my co-hosts in the same room, and bring video into the mix the way I had watched it done at Emmis Broadcasting… when I worked at Hot 97 in its early days. The vision was real. When the opportunity came to relocate to a beautiful studio in downtown Brooklyn… attached to an established brand, with a legitimate lineup of other live shows around us… I said yes.
The new setup’s backend ran on one of the best live radio streaming platforms out there. But it didn’t have the social component built in. And without that, the ability to take calls was kind of useless. That was the primary driver of the show’s energy. We had upgraded everything except the thing that made the show the show.
The Shift
We didn’t realize it at first. But the audience did… almost immediately.
In just 3 months, we lost over 75% of our listeners. Not because the quality went down. Not because the content got worse. But because we had changed the dynamic of the experience. We had forced our listeners to either receive the show on our terms… or find somewhere else to go.
They found somewhere else to go.
We struggled to gain a new audience with the same brand loyalty we hat at BTR.
When we eventually returned to Blog Talk Radio to try and recapture the “magic”, I wrote this:
“Our decision to return to Blog Talk Radio was based on your feedback. Many of you missed the interactivity of our first two years of broadcasting. When at BTR, you felt like you owned the show and it was hard to make you happy at our new home.”
Re-reading that now, years later, it lands differently.
You felt like you owned the show.
That’s not a complaint. That’s the highest compliment a community can give you. And we had accidentally taken it away from them in pursuit of a better-looking studio… and look “legit”
But here’s the part that stings most in hindsight… coming back wasn’t enough. The audience had moved on. Found new shows. Built new habits. We came home to a house that no longer felt like ours. The show went on hiatus.
It never came back.
A lesson learned the hard way. And one I carry into everything I build now.
The Platform Is Not the People
Here’s the lesson I keep coming back to: your community doesn’t live inside any platform. They live in the relationship you’ve built with them. But platforms shape that relationship… sometimes in ways you don’t notice until you’ve already signed.
When you move, you’re not just changing where the show lives. You’re changing who can find it, who can share it, who can afford it, and whether new people can stumble into it organically.
If and when The Breakfast Club leaves Netflix and comes back to YouTube, there is no guarantee their former audience will follow. The short-term gain might lead to long-term pain.
That’s the real risk. Not the Netflix deal itself. It’s that the audience you trained to find you in one place may not follow you to the next one. And in a world where attention is the real currency, you can’t assume loyalty travels automatically.
I got to come back. The question for The Breakfast Club is whether Netflix becomes a launchpad or a landing pad. Whether this deal opens new doors without closing the ones their community has been walking through for fifteen years.
The numbers are already talking.
And I am watching.
Another Post You May Enjoy: Social Media Strategy for Podcasting
What Creators Can Take From This
Before you take the exclusive deal, the platform pivot, the bag that requires you to lock out your community… ask yourself a few things:
Where does my community actually live right now, and will they follow me?
Does this move build my ownership or just my visibility?
Am I changing platforms… or changing who can afford to be in the room?
Is this a door opening… or a door I’m closing behind me?
The Breakfast Club built something real. Fifteen years of interviews, culture, controversy, and community. That doesn’t vanish overnight. But the move reminds us that even the most established brands are one platform shift away from starting over.
The bag is real. But community is the real algorithm.
Choose wisely.
Con amor,
George Torres
Founder – Siembra Connect
George Torres is the founder of Siembra Connect, a digital strategy and creator newsletter platform rooted in community-first growth. He has spent nearly three decades building Latino cultural media online… before the algorithms, before the platforms, and before anyone called it content. He writes about culture, community, and the real cost of chasing the bag.
Siembra Connect
Thank you, George, for this insightful take. Creators do have a lot to think about when what may seem like a big deal comes because the grass may not always be greener.
With Love, Heidy
Sign up for my newsletter to receive free weekly podcast mentorship and more BTS content on what it takes to produce two podcasts, be a speaker, coach, and content creator.